Barbie doesn’t always get ballet right. Early “ballerina Barbie” dolls seemed more inspired by girlish fantasies of pink tulle than any reality. Their pointe shoe ribbons, meant to support the ankles, often laced fancifully up the calves; their limited joints made achieving most ballet positions impossible.
Barbie became a kind of dance-world punchline: My ballet teacher used to warn against “Barbie hands,” with tense wrists and frozen fingers.
But some dancers have a soft spot for one corner of the Barbieverse. In the 2000s, Mattel released a series of computer-animated films — “Barbie in the Nutcracker” (2001), “Barbie of Swan Lake” (2003), “Barbie in the 12 Dancing Princesses” (2006) and “Barbie in the Pink Shoes” (2013) — that used New York City Ballet dancers as models. In a bit of inspired casting, the impossibly long-limbed City Ballet star Maria Kowroski did Barbie’s dancing in the first three films. The animated Barbie and her companions accordingly boast remarkable, even beautiful, ballet technique.
Many of today’s ballet dancers grew up with these movies. Chloe Misseldine, now a principal with American Ballet Theater, said in an interview last year that “Barbie of Swan Lake” was her introduction to the “Swan Lake” story as a child. In March, the San Francisco Ballet stars Madeline Woo and Nikisha Fogo affectionately recreated choreography from “Barbie in the 12 Dancing Princesses” and “Barbie in the Nutcracker.” The popular Gen Z YouTubers Jordan and Eden Lim, known as Ballet Reign, have painstakingly analyzed all four movies step by step.
This month, 25 years after the release of the original film, Netflix premiered a new animated “Barbie in the Nutcracker.” Like its predecessors, it has an impressive dance pedigree. The formidable Debbie Allen choreographed and helped produce the 45-minute movie, and young performers from the Debbie Allen Dance Academy in Los Angeles enacted the dance sequences.
The choreography goes well beyond ballet. “We’ve got tap dance going on in there,” Allen said in a video interview from Los Angeles. “There’s some hip-hop going on in there. Yes, there’s some ballet. We’ve got all of it.”
The story line has also changed. While the original was a coming-of-age tale about a Barbie named Clara and her romantic love for the Nutcracker Prince, the new film focuses on the friendship of two Barbies: Malibu, who is white, and Brooklyn, who is Black. After they have an argument, a dream sequence transforms Malibu into Clara and Brooklyn into the Sugar Plum Fairy; the two must work together to defeat the evil Rat King and save the Nutcracker, a.k.a. Ken.
Allen — who has her own Barbie doll, costumed for her signature “Fame” role — said she helped steer the film in a direction she thought would speak to modern audiences.
“Originally there was a thought of it being very classic,” Allen said. “I said, ‘Well, what is classic?’” She wanted the dancing and the story to nod to traditional “Nutcracker” productions and to the original Barbie film, while “expanding the borders of toy land into the real world,” she said.
Barbie and ballet have a long history, which ties into ballet’s deep and often complicated relationship with dolls. Mara Mandradjieff, a former professional dancer who is now a professor at Emory University, said in a video interview that dolls dressed as ballet dancers began to appear in the 1800s. Several late 19th-century ballets featured dancers portraying dolls, including “Coppélia” (1870) and “The Nutcracker” (1892).
Often, these kinds of doll ballets involved shaping or animating an idealized female body — one of ballet’s most enduring preoccupations. When Barbie dolls, with their biologically unlikely proportions, first appeared in 1959, they offered a similarly unattainable womanly ideal.
“Barbie and ballet kind of go together,” Mandradjieff said, “because they’ve both played a very large role in defining or perpetuating what femininity ‘should’ look like.”
The first ballet outfit for Barbie arrived in 1961, and the first dedicated ballerina Barbie hit the market in 1976. There are now myriad Barbies available, but as of 2022, a Mattel representative said, ballerina was still among the most popular Barbie career dolls (along with pop star, doctor and firefighter).
The Barbie ballet movies of the 2000s had plenty of the sparkly pink ensembles that had by then become ballerina-Barbie hallmarks. But they also showed a new interest in real technique.
“I remember we were very careful to make sure that when Barbie was dancing that it was correct — the turnout, the position of the legs, the shaping of the feet,” said Kowroski, the Barbie model in three films, who is now the artistic director of New Jersey Ballet.
On the 2001 “Barbie in the Nutcracker” set, Kowroski and her Ken-slash-Nutcracker, the City Ballet principal Charles Askegard, wore motion-capture suits to help the animators record their dancing. Kowroski remembers making adjustments to their partnering to accommodate the electronic sensors affixed to their bodies.
“The most challenging part was for us not to laugh at each other,” she said. “The little sensor balls kept falling off, and when they did, you know, half your body would disappear on the screen.”
But Kowroski was impressed by the resulting animation. “People said to me, ‘We’re going to be able to tell that you were the model just because of the way Barbie’s legs look in an arabesque,’” she said. “I was like, ‘No way.’ But then when I saw it, I was like, ‘Oh, yeah — that’s definitely me.’” (She did think Barbie’s stiff animated arms were less true to life, she said.)
Animation technology has advanced significantly over the past two decades. Chrisette Parkinson, the gifted 13-year-old student who modeled for Brooklyn in the new “Barbie in the Nutcracker,” didn’t need motion-capture suits and sensors. Instead, each choreographed section was filmed from several angles. The animation team was able to recreate the dancers’ steps using that footage, a Mattel representative said.
“We had to dance really big, nothing little, because they needed to be able to capture all of our movements,” Parkinson said.
To see herself as Brooklyn in the final film was thrilling, she said. “Getting to watch it and knowing that I was the skeleton inside the character — I still can’t believe it.”
Real-life Barbie dolls have become “better” at ballet over time. The 2016 Misty Copeland doll, created in the likeness of the trailblazing former American Ballet Theater principal, featured a flexible body designed with Copeland’s input. The new Barbie “Nutcracker” film arrived with a suite of accompanying dolls (of course), some of which feature updated joints that allow them to stand on pointe.
The Debbie Allen Barbie doll has a wide range of movement. “Now they make Barbies with the legs going all kind of ways,” Allen said, laughing.
And in the 25 years since the original “Barbie in the Nutcracker” premiered, there have been more philosophical shifts in ballet and in Barbieland, too. Both worlds, Mandradjieff said, have made gestures toward racial and body-size inclusivity, showing greater self-awareness about the problematic aspects of their past.
“I think ballet and Barbie have been in the process of redefining themselves,” Mandradjieff said.
The new “Barbie in the Nutcracker” reflects that evolution, especially in its casting of Brooklyn as the Sugar Plum Fairy. Allen described seeing a Black character in that classical role as powerfully symbolic.
“Brooklyn Barbie is the Sugar Plum!” she said. “She will help every family feel included.”
Parkinson — who is now preparing to dance multiple roles in Allen’s annual “Hot Chocolate Nutcracker” production — thinks the main takeaway from the film is movement’s power to bridge divides, she said.
“The Brooklyn doll and the Malibu doll get into an argument,” she said, “and you might have squabbles with your friend, too. But you can dance the squabbles away.”