Resident Alien doesn’t waste time reminding us who it is. The Season 4 premiere, titled “Prison,” throws us right back into the chaos, equal parts absurd, heartfelt, and existential.
And true to the episode’s name, nearly every character is stuck somewhere they don’t want to be, literally or emotionally. I found myself thinking about the word in a dozen different ways by the time the episode wrapped.
Even Harry’s signature voiceovers lean into it: humans, he tells us, are already living in prisons — of fear, belief, routine. And for once, he might be more right than weird.
Harry’s Literal Prison
When we first see Harry, he’s wandering an alien ship with a baby alien strapped to his back, misnaming D’arcy as “Darby” and “Arby.” It’s a laugh-out-loud moment. But what follows cuts deeper.
He meets a man claiming to be a pizza delivery guy — Pizza Jay — who turns out to be a mantid in disguise. In short order, Harry’s locked up, betrayed by his love of pepperoni.
And this is where it gets surprisingly emotional.
Harry’s stuck in a cell, growing a beard, stripped of control. He talks to Bridget like she’s his prison yard boss. He reminisces about the people in his life — even the ones he didn’t like.
Isolation has changed him. I don’t know that Harry ever thought he had people to miss before, but now he does. In past seasons, he wrestled with the idea of why humans tie themselves in knots over the people in their lives. Now he understands what it feels like to lose them. And it hurts.
The Mantid Among Us
Meanwhile, mantid Harry is loose in Patience. Slicked-back hair. Cigarette in hand. Zero filters. He’s unhinged, obnoxious, and shockingly unnoticed. I kept waiting for someone — anyone — to say, “That’s not our Harry,” but no one does. Not even Asta.
That’s the point. The show plays it for laughs, sure, but it also makes a haunting observation: how well do we really know each other? And what does it say about the people around Harry that they miss the difference entirely?
It’s not even the first time with the same Harry. We often imagine ourselves to be invisible to those around us, but has anyone ever been as invisible as anyone wearing Harry Vanderspeigle’s skin suit? The difference between our Harry and mantid Harry is easy for us to spot.
Is everyone so wrapped up in their own stuff that they can’t? The mantid is aggressive, whereas Harry is odd. He pushes boundaries instead of stumbling over them. The wrongness is evident to us, but not to them. That disconnect becomes the episode’s most unsettling thread.
Kate & Ben: Broken and Blindsided
Kate is grieving, and instead of collapsing into a heap, she’s punching a dummy that definitely looks like Ben. She’s unrelenting, angry, and laser-focused on getting her baby back.
Ben, as usual, means well but misses the point. When he follows a clue that turns out to be a woman misheard on a 911 call, it’s sad, funny, and painfully Ben.
Their marriage is a minefield of chemistry, resentment, and raw love. Meredith Garretson makes Kate’s emotional rollercoaster feel earned. She’s not fragile — she’s furious. And Ben, in his own awkward way, is trying to keep up.
But they’re parenting blind. Max’s powers are still under wraps, and neither of them has any idea what’s unfolding right under their noses.
D’arcy & Asta: Parenting in Hiding
D’arcy is playing mom now, and she’s good at it — too good. She’s named Kate’s baby Daisy, woven a backstory about a cousin, and set up spy cams in Ben and Kate’s house.
It’s over the top and completely on-brand. But it’s also emotional. D’arcy loves this baby. Maybe too much. And Asta sees the writing on the wall.
Asta, meanwhile, is being pulled in a hundred directions and finally starting to wonder what she wants. She’s cared for Harry, Jay, D’arcy, and the entire town of Patience. Now she’s asking herself a rare question: “What now?” For someone like Asta, that’s terrifying — and exciting.
Also? She’s getting some.
Joseph may be an alien hybrid with a suspicious résumé and questionable pillow talk, but he definitely qualifies as a “rebound with benefits.” Even D’arcy is impressed. Asta’s not exactly broadcasting it, but we know. D’arcy knows.
And while the whole thing ends about as awkwardly as you’d expect (complete with Joseph misreading every signal and stumbling over himself to score another date that Asta keeps at arm’s length), I can’t blame Asta for taking a win where she can get one.
It’s messy, it’s weird, and it’s very Patience.
And Sara Tomko gives Asta the kind of quiet purpose that sneaks up on you. She isn’t a woman ready to bolt. She is a woman ready to become whatever and wherever that may be.
Liv & Mike: Emotional Prison Break
Liv may be the MVP of this episode. She’s hiking mountains, caring for what’s left of Peter Bach, and still managing to challenge Mike when he tries to check out. She’s lost weight — noticeably so — and she’s not shy about pointing it out (without saying the words).
Mike and Ben both awkwardly agree not to say anything because they don’t want to imply she didn’t look great before. But here’s the thing: if you don’t say anything, sometimes it feels like the hard work goes unseen. So let’s say it.
Liv looked great before. And she looks great now.
More importantly, she’s stronger now — physically, emotionally, and spiritually. We’ve always known she was the heart of the show, but now we’re seeing her flex in new ways.
She’s standing up for herself, demanding better, and refusing to let people she cares about disappear into denial. The women in this town are all in a state of becoming better people, especially to themselves.
Mike, for his part, is still in retreat mode. He thinks his alien encounter was a hallucination, and he’s taken a leave from his job. But Liv doesn’t let him wallow in it. She needs him back. And even though Mike is reluctant, we see glimmers of the man he used to be.
Quietly hanging a new uniform in her office — with a bow and a note that says this one should fit — is as close to a love letter as Mike gets.
These two are always dancing around emotion, but they’re starting to move in sync. The town might not notice it yet, but we do.
Voiceovers, Themes, and Final Thoughts
Harry’s voiceovers are as sharp and thought-provoking as ever.
He reflects on prison as both a concept and a reality, about how humans trap themselves in beliefs, fears, and limitations. About how freedom isn’t just about open doors — it’s about the courage to walk through them.
He talks about faith — in others, in yourself — and I actually felt it. That’s the show’s magic.
One minute it’s a mantid punting Bridget across the room, and the next, it’s a tearful alien longing to visit Earth because he believes there’s something better waiting for him. Almost every time, I’m caught off-guard, tears welling in my eyes.
This wasn’t a “big” episode by sci-fi standards. There were no epic battles and the planetary threats were at a minimum. But emotionally, it packed a punch. Everyone is caged and struggling to get free.
I’m just glad the show’s back. From the outside, it looks like a sci-fi comedy. But really, it’s about what it means to be human — and how hard we’re all trying to figure it out. It gets harder every day to spot the difference, but Resident Alien reminds us of how messy being human really is.
Season 4 is already shaping up to be one of the show’s most personal and character-driven yet, and I’ll be here every week to dig into the details.
If you missed our exclusive interviews, now’s the perfect time to catch up — creator Chris Sheridan offered insight into the show’s emotional center, while Corey Reynolds, Elizabeth Bowen, Meredith Garretson, and Sara Tomko opened up about their characters’ shifting dynamics this season.
Got thoughts about the premiere? Favorite moments? Let’s hear them!
Drop a comment below, share the review with your fellow Patience truthers, and stick with us as we unpack the strange, hilarious, and heart-filled journey ahead.
Watch Resident-Alien Online
Resident Alien Stars Meredith Garretson and Sara Tomko on Motherhood, Growth, and the Power of Self-Discovery
Meredith Garretson & Sara Tomko explore Resident Alien Season 4’s emotional depths, from alien trauma to self-love, and what it all means for Kate and Asta.
Resident Alien’s Corey Reynolds & Elizabeth Bowen Reflect on Wonder, Weariness, and What’s Next
Resident Alien stars Corey Reynolds & Elizabeth Bowen dig into Season 4, character growth, alien awe, and why Mike & Liv are the show’s secret heart.
Resident Alien’s Chris Sheridan Promises a Game-Changer in Season 4
Resident Alien showrunner Chris Sheridan teases big themes, wild twists, and emotional moments in Season 4 — plus what makes this ensemble so special.
The post Resident Alien Season 4 Premiere Review: “Prison” Locks Everyone in More Ways Than One appeared first on TV Fanatic.